Sumit Shekhar Reviewer
Approved
Relevance and Originality
The manuscript examines the socio cultural evolution of Cooch Behar with emphasis on the Rajbanshi community. The topic is relevant to regional history and cultural studies. The paper provides useful documentation, although the originality would improve with a clearer research gap and stronger analytical perspective.
Methodology
The study is based on historical records, published literature, and supporting field observations. The approach is appropriate for the objectives, but greater explanation of source selection and analytical methods would improve methodological transparency.
Validity and Reliability
The discussion is supported by historical references and documented sources. However, greater critical evaluation of historical narratives and broader comparison with recent scholarship would strengthen the reliability of the conclusions.
Clarity and Structure
The manuscript follows a logical sequence covering food, religion, festivals, folk traditions, and social customs. Some sections are lengthy and descriptive, requiring language refinement and improved transitions for better readability.
Results and Analysis
The paper successfully documents important cultural practices and changing traditions in Cooch Behar. The analysis would become stronger with deeper interpretation of the cultural transformations rather than primarily descriptive presentation.
Sumit Shekhar Reviewer