Rajesh Tirupathi Reviewer
30 May 2025 01:30 PM

Relevance and Originality
This research tackles a pressing problem in the field of neurodevelopmental diagnostics by offering a unified pipeline for early ASD detection, something often missing in previous approaches. The originality lies in merging feature selection, behavioral grouping, and class balancing into one cohesive framework. By structuring these diverse elements into a modular design, the work advances the field beyond conventional, disjointed models and aligns closely with real-world clinical demands for interpretable and scalable solutions in autism prediction.
Methodology
The study employs a layered approach where each stage of the pipeline addresses a known weakness in ASD data processing. The normalization phase prepares the dataset efficiently, while the FlexiFeat component smartly merges multiple feature selection techniques, enhancing dimensional relevance. The hybrid clustering using K-Means and DBSCAN provides behavioral structuring, and the integration of Cluster-SMOTE at the class rebalancing stage directly confronts data skewness. Concluding with a soft-voting classifier ensemble ensures classification strength, making this method not only well-rounded but technically refined.
Validity & Reliability
The performance outcomes provide a solid foundation for the study’s claims. High scores across various metrics—including accuracy, recall, and MCC—suggest a model that is both precise and generalizable. The balanced evaluation methodology ensures each component of the model contributes effectively to the outcome. However, while internal validation appears thorough, future studies should explore how well this framework performs across diverse population datasets to fully confirm its reliability in broader clinical applications.
Clarity and Structure
The structure of the research is systematic and easy to follow, guiding the reader through the five pipeline phases in a logical manner. Terminologies are well explained, and the transitions between concepts maintain coherence. The description of each technical process is sufficiently detailed, without overwhelming the reader. Some aspects, such as the interaction between clustering and synthetic oversampling, might benefit from visual representation to enhance understanding of the methodology’s flow.
Result Analysis
The reported outcomes are comprehensive and directly support the utility of the proposed system. By presenting a comparative performance benchmark against existing techniques, the research highlights its innovation and superiority clearly. The interpretation of results is consistent with the design goals of the pipeline and showcases how thoughtful integration of machine learning elements can lead to substantial improvement in ASD classification.
Rajesh Tirupathi Reviewer
30 May 2025 01:29 PM