Network Monitoring and Analysis with Wireshark

Approved

Relevance and Originality

The project addresses a critical area in cybersecurity and network management, focusing on the practical application of Wireshark for monitoring and analyzing network traffic. This relevance is underscored by the growing importance of network security in enterprise environments. The originality of the work lies in its hands-on approach to using Wireshark, highlighting not just theoretical aspects but also practical methodologies. To enhance originality, the authors could explore novel use cases or integrations with other tools to demonstrate Wireshark's unique capabilities.

Methodology

The project outlines a solid methodology for evaluating network traffic using Wireshark, detailing how various protocols are analyzed. However, it would benefit from a more structured presentation of the methodologies used. Clearly defining the steps taken to capture and analyze data, as well as any parameters set during the analysis, would add rigor. Including examples of specific scenarios or case studies where these methodologies have been applied successfully would further strengthen this section.

Validity & Reliability

While the project emphasizes Wireshark's capabilities, empirical data supporting its effectiveness in real-world applications would enhance the validity of the findings. Presenting case studies or statistical data on the accuracy of detection methods would provide a more reliable basis for claims. Additionally, addressing potential limitations or challenges faced when using Wireshark, such as false positives in attack detection, would create a more balanced view of its applicability.

Clarity and Structure

The overall clarity of the project is satisfactory, but the structure could be improved. Organizing the content into distinct sections such as "Introduction," "Methodology," "Results," and "Discussion" would facilitate easier navigation and understanding. The use of clear headings and subheadings would help guide the reader through the various aspects of network monitoring and attack detection. Visual aids, such as diagrams or flowcharts, could further enhance comprehension of complex processes.

Result Analysis

The analysis of Wireshark's capabilities in detecting network attacks, specifically port scanning, is an important aspect of the project. However, it would be beneficial to provide more detailed results from actual use cases, including metrics such as detection rates and response times. Discussing the implications of these findings for network administrators and the broader context of cybersecurity would enrich the conclusion. Recommendations for future research or potential improvements in monitoring techniques would also be valuable contributions to the field.