PRONOY CHOPRA Reviewer
30 May 2025 01:23 PM

Relevance and Originality
The research presents a highly relevant and innovative approach to autism detection by addressing three core challenges: feature relevance, behavioral variability, and class imbalance. By introducing the ASD-Pipeline, which unifies adaptive feature selection, clustering-based behavioral grouping, and synthetic data balancing, the study offers a fresh contribution to the field. The framework’s integration of techniques like ensemble learning, autism detection, and class imbalance resolution sets it apart from conventional models and underscores its originality in tackling a complex neurodevelopmental issue.
Methodology
The methodology is comprehensive and logically structured, combining Min-Max normalization, an ensemble feature selector (FlexiFeat), hybrid clustering with K-Means and DBSCAN, Cluster-SMOTE for class imbalance handling, and an ensemble classifier using Logistic Regression, Support Vector Machine, and Gradient Boosting. Each stage supports the next in a cohesive flow, enhancing the overall pipeline's effectiveness in autism detection and behavioral clustering. This integrated use of normalization, feature engineering, and machine learning techniques strengthens the pipeline's applicability in real-world datasets.
Validity & Reliability
The findings appear robust and well-supported, with the ASD-Pipeline achieving high scores across various performance metrics, including 96.18% accuracy, over 91% precision and recall, and strong values for F1-score and specificity. The inclusion of the Matthews Correlation Coefficient reinforces the credibility of the results by providing a balanced performance view. Although internal validity is strong, the study's reliability would be further enhanced with external validation using independent datasets, particularly given the emphasis on autism detection and predictive modeling.
Clarity and Structure
The article is well-organized, with a coherent presentation of the problem, proposed solution, and evaluation. Explanations for each pipeline stage are clear, contributing to strong interpretability. The language used is accessible while maintaining the technical precision necessary for topics such as feature selection, class imbalance, and ensemble learning. Despite its strengths, the addition of visual aids like diagrams or flowcharts could enhance clarity, especially for readers less familiar with behavioral clustering and machine learning frameworks.
Result Analysis
The result interpretation is thorough and data-driven, highlighting the pipeline’s superior performance across various benchmarks. The comparison with existing techniques is detailed and convincingly supports the study’s claims. The use of multiple performance indicators allows for a nuanced understanding of how the proposed system outperforms previous models in autism detection and behavioral variability handling.
PRONOY CHOPRA Reviewer
30 May 2025 01:21 PM