Hemasundara Reddy Lanka Reviewer
04 Apr 2025 09:28 PM

This paper offers a comprehensive and insightful examination of data management practices and machine learning adoption across Indian financial institutions, including public/private sector banks, fintechs, and insurance firms. It is timely and relevant, given the rapid digitization of India's financial ecosystem and the growing importance of data governance in compliance, customer analytics, and risk management.
The study's strength lies in its multi-sectoral coverage, use of mixed-methodology, and integration of regulatory considerations (e.g., RBI, SEBI, IRDAI). The presentation of use cases through well-structured tables provides practical value for industry practitioners and regulators alike.
However, a few areas require further elaboration to enhance the academic rigor and clarity of the paper.
Terminology Clarification
- Define what is meant by “accuracy” in the context of ML models (especially when comparing across use cases) and “adoption level” (is it based on institutional investment, breadth of use, or pilot-to-production transition?).
Citations and Referencing
- Some cited works (e.g., Gupta et al. 2022, Mukherjee & Roy 2021) are missing full references. Please ensure all citations include titles, journals, and DOIs where applicable.
Visual Enhancements
- Consider using infographics or radar charts to visually depict the variance in maturity across sectors or to illustrate ML use case adoption levels.
Ethical Considerations Expansion
- While anonymization and consent are covered, it would be valuable to discuss data bias risks in ML models used for credit scoring or fraud detection—especially given potential socio-economic implications in the Indian context.
Conclusion Structuring
- The conclusion currently reads more like an extended discussion. Consider restructuring it to clearly articulate:
- Key contributions of the study
- Implications for policymakers, regulators, and financial data managers
- Future directions (e.g., role of federated learning, blockchain in auditability, real-time compliance platforms)
Hemasundara Reddy Lanka Reviewer
04 Apr 2025 09:16 PM