Vishwasrao Salunkhe Reviewer
14 Nov 2025 05:37 PM
Approved
Relevance & Originality:
The paper addresses an important and timely issue—the need for resilient banking operations during network disruptions. The idea of combining LAN-based ATM operations with blockchain-powered validation is interesting and relatively unexplored. The overall concept demonstrates novelty, especially the hybrid BFT model for offline transaction approval.
Methodology:
The system architecture is described clearly, but the methodology would benefit from deeper explanation. Key components such as the hybrid BFT algorithm, synchronization mechanism, and liquidity rules need more technical detailing. A formal system model and flow diagrams would strengthen the work.
Validity & Reliability:
The performance metrics (99.7% success rate and 2.3-second processing time) are promising, but the paper lacks clarity on test environment, sample size, and simulation conditions. Without this, it is difficult to assess the robustness of the findings. Additional validation scenarios—e.g., stress testing, failure cases, and comparison with existing fallback systems—would improve reliability.
Clarity & Structure:
The abstract is well-written and logically structured. However, the paper should clarify how blockchain operates in a fully offline LAN environment, and how consensus is ensured across distributed nodes without external connectivity. Including a brief workflow of transaction execution during outages would make the approach easier to understand.
Result Analysis:
The results are encouraging but need more detail on evaluation parameters. It would help to discuss the trade-offs such as cost, scalability, branch-wise implementation complexity, and potential latency introduced by BFT under intranet constraints.
Overall Evaluation:
The research presents a practical and innovative solution for maintaining critical banking services during emergencies. With additional technical depth, clearer experimental details, and expanded validation, the paper can make a strong contribution to financial system resilience research.

Vishwasrao Salunkhe Reviewer